Then there s the ridiculous romance aspects of the story Because 15 year olds are such noble romantic creatures that form lasting, twu wuv bonds And, yet again, how many times do we need to see the Do you have a crush on someone conversation played out It was awkward the first time, and the second time, and the every fucking time It felt like a grown man was trying to write teenagers talking about their crushes That s right It was that Seriously, I think that the author really has no idea what a crush is, and thinks that it s either True Love, Soulmate style, or the most dedicated and creepy stalker behavior ever I m not sure which, but both were depicted in this book, so maybe that s my answer It s sure as hell not depicted in any way that s realistic Hey, you re cute and cool and I like sitting 3 rows behind you in math I ll write your initials and my initials together in a heart shape inside a notebook that I ll never show to another soul ever, and I ll fantasize about what it would be like to go out with you But I m not going to die for you, or with you, and if it looks like there s a chance you ll be attracting danger, I m abandoning you because I don t really fucking know you, and this ain t Romeo and Juliet You re just kinda cute There are lots of kinda cute people out there Sorry Then there are the semi apologies in advance I didn t tell you, but, here s an explanation of something that I had no reason to ever think to tell you previously because it s seriously irrelevant to anything but this exact situation right now, and you didn t need to know it anyway But sorry I didn t tell you Or It might be disrespectful to say this, but, I am going to finish this sentence by saying something completely banal This one is probably a culture thing, to be fair Or I don t know what to say, but, right now the words coming out of my mouth are going to be something appropriate to say in this situation, which is the very thing I said I didn t know how to say when I started this sentence That s right I just remembered the thing that I had forgotten until right now, which is that this kind of sentence occurred way too fucking often in this book That s right I ve come to a conclusion That s right I just remembered to say the thing I just thought of to say That s right, I just thought of a question Can I ask you a question That s right, the question would be right here That s right, now I m going to say things that I just remembered or decided to say That s right blah blah blah blah I think it s probably a good thing that I don t have this book in e book format, because I d be so tempted to search key words and phrases just to see how many times they re actually used I m that annoyed with this book I want stats and numbers to quantify my suffering I have no idea why this book is so highly regarded, except that it s reached cult classic status, and therefore it MUST be amazing Oh, dang it I just broke my sarcasm key sigh Edited First to correct a typo, and second to add some commentary about the point of this book, which is from one of my posts in the discussion below I did actually get the point of this At the end, it s put out there that having this kind of Program is useful for controlling the populace They the people don t know the rules and the details, they just know of the Program and see it through the lens that the government wants them to They see it as a competition, that people are ruthless and willing to kill, or at least use others to protect themselves, and that it s everyone for themselves This, combined with the fear tactics that the government uses hauling people away to re education camps or just outright killing them makes the probability of someone gathering people together to fight against the government unlikely because nobody can really trust that the others aren t going to betray them It s actually effective, and had this been less painful to read, I d probably have loved it But the writing got in the way of the message, I think.
Before reading this book, I believe Ms Collins, author of The Hunger Games, had ripped off Battle Royale, and after reading BR the novel, I continue to believe THG is a rip off For example 1 different bags of weapons and food given by the government 2 the battle filed gets smaller everyday 3 view spoiler two winners in the end instead of just one hide spoiler Koushun Takami S Notorious High Octane Thriller Is Based On An Irresistible Premise A Class Of Junior High School Students Is Taken To A Deserted Island Where, As Part Of A Ruthless Authoritarian Program, They Are Provided Arms And Forced To Kill One Another Until Only One Survivor Is Left Standing Criticized As Violent Exploitation When First Published In Japan Where It Then Proceeded To Become A Runaway Bestseller Battle Royale Is A Lord Of The Flies For The St Century, A Potent Allegory Of What It Means To Be Young And Barely Alive In A Dog Eat Dog World Made Into A Controversial Hit Movie Of The Same Name, Battle Royale Is Already A Contemporary Japanese Pulp Classic, Now Available For The First Time In The English Language I FINALLY FINISHED WOW.
In my opinion, this book could and should have been way shorter The only reason this book is so long is because the author felt it necessary to go into tons of detail about each character s backstory before killing them off I can see why some people might like that, but it didn t work for me.
I really enjoyed the ending though, so I m glad I pushed through I also loved how brutal this book was, both in terms of the violence and the way the characters interacted with each other They swore and did all sorts of crazy things, and none of that is hidden from the reader which I thought was really refreshing This one is definitely not your typical YA novel if you d even call it that So overall I enjoyed this, but obviously didn t LOVE it.
A busload of Japanese teenagers is kidnapped and dumped off on an island, where they are forced to fight to the death until one student remains, all in the name of The Program Which of the 42 students will survive I remember hearing about the film version of Battle Royale ages ago but never managed to watch it Seeing that a lot of people compare The Hunger Games to Battle Royale, I figured I should give it a shot and I m quite glad I did Battle Royale is The Hunger Games with gore and without the annoying love triangle.
Battle Royale takes place in an alternate present, where Japan is largely a totalitarian police state Every year, a class is chosen for The Program, a free for all that makes Thunderdome look like an episode of The Care Bears Each student is given a backpack and a weapon and turned loose one at a time To make things interesting, there are forbidden zones on the island and anyone caught in one is killed instantly via the explosive collar they are all forced to wear Sound good People are killed right off the bat and the book never lets up I had a pretty good idea who would survive based on who got the most time on screen but the journey was well worth it Kazuo and Mitsuko both needed their hash settled from the opening bell.
I mentioned gore earlier and this book has than its share of gruesome killings Hatchets to the face, many, many stabbings, gunshots galore, and lots of betrayal and deception on top of it.
The writing was also pretty good Aside from a couple very minor hiccups, I would never guess it was a translation In the afterword, Takami mentions Stephen King and Robert Parker as his big influences and I think it shows in the text The explosive collars are straight out of the Running Man movie not from the novel The intro reminded me of the intro to Needful Things.
Since I m only giving it a four, I guess I ll complain about a couple things Shuya didn t have much personality enough though he was supposed to be the hero Kazuo was overly powerful and seemed to have unlimited ammo It was hard to keep track of who was who at times because of similar sounding names However, all these were minor complaints and I found Battle Royale to be quite an enjoyable read Four out of five stars.
Videorecensione film perla vera di un regista storico come Kinji Fukasaku stato un must della mia preadolescenza Visto un milione di volte e amato alla follia Per qualche motivo, non avevo mai letto il romanzo Lacuna che ho colmato durante queste brevi vacanze Il libro oggettivamente scritto male male, ma scorre liscio, avvincendo e tenendo incollati talmente tanto che queste 670 pagine scorrono in un battibaleno Che bello ritrovare personaggi che nel film avevo amato come Shuya, Shogo, Noriko, Takako, Mitsuko e Hiroki qui ancora pi approfonditi I pro del romanzo Una maggiore attenzione sulle tematiche politiche e satiriche sulla distopia e la natura del gioco del massacro che nel film vengono tralasciate e un forte studio psicologico di TUTTI i personaggi per ovvie ragioni, il film tagliava le storie degli studenti meno centrali, ma che bello scoprire il background di Yoshimi, personaggio pi complesso di quel che sembra , dando loro quasi egual importanza Sebbene alcune scene splatter restino insuperate nel film, per creativit e estro visionario l epica scena del faro risulta, nel romanzo, molto pi piatta , il libro maggiormente crudele e sanguinario.
Se poi la forte attenzione alla sfera romantica dei legami tra studenti pu sembrare inizialmente estremismo manga, ben presto si svela vincente nella caratterizzazione psicologica degli stessi adolescenti ancora non uomini e donne , costretti a diventare adulti in una societ molto vicina alla realt competitiva, dove la sopravvivenza segue logiche darwiniste, lontana dall empatia e la collaborazione Non mancano i difetti soprattutto di scrittura , ma Battle Royale uno young adult di classe, infinite spanne sopra il 90% della roba analoga che esce recentemente.
I read the first hundred pages of Battle Royale and fell asleep That night I dreamt that I was in The Program I remember fleeing a pretty intense gunfight and thinking nonsensically dammit, at least I m getting good exercise I hardly thought about it until the next evening, when I began to read again and only finished as the sun rose You cannot know gunfights or car chases until you ve read Battle Royale.
It s fantastical, it s pulpy, and it s brilliant I wish it had been written with realism, but you can t have everything Perhaps Koushun Takami will write another, some day.
There s this rumor that Suzanne Collins ripped off the idea for The Hunger Games from Battle Royale After reading the supposed original, I could say that the plot for both books are pretty similar but Koushun Takami s novel is of an entirely different league it s quite incomparable Battle Royale does have a very colorful and well handled take on the the fight to the death premise than anything I have ever read before It s a book of mass slaughter than forty deaths and practically each one is described, and a litany of brutality and betrayal that even in its many variations, can be a bit of overkill Still, for such a long book littered with so many bodies, Takami manages to keep things moving, and hold my interest There s constant tension, and a few good surprises There are too many characters to really get much of a sense of many of them, but the strongest point of the novel describes how some characters descend into madness, while others keep their wits This psychological element is like a twisted reflection of high school life which can often seem this brutal sans the bloody consequences In extreme situations, true colours are shown, and they re often surprising ones The narrative is quite riveting, and there are a lot of moments when I want to throw up and cry, and jump up and down at the same time.
I have a few qualms though, including the fact that the program is so enormous with fifty classes a year That s roughly 2000 students killed, quite a huge casualty for even a large nation to take The purpose of the program is never really made clear either It s also important to note that the translation isn t as great as it should have been It doesn t hinder the plot, but a him is called a her every once in a while and some helpful adjectives are left out.
In the end, I could still say that Battle Royale is a perfectly fine thriller, with a fun premise and a well drawn out story If you plan to read it, I suggest that you pick up the graphic novels too, they are visually stunning and just as riveting.
So unputdownable it s ridiculous Took a 4 hour plane ride i intended to sleep on and instead read all 624 pages of this and while I m a fast reader, even I m not THAT fast usually.
Basically, as everyone else is saying, it s a book about one class of Japanese junior high kids put on an island with a small bag of supplies, a random weapon grenade crossbow Uzi fork , an exploding tracking collar, and orders to kill, kill, kill Nice fascist dystopia world you see around the edges of this place, but it doesn t go into so much detail you re distracted from the good stuff And the good stuff is watching all the little petty relationships of being 15 suddenly twisted horribly by the extreme fear of knowing only one person will be allowed to live It s ridiculous, and it s full of eye popping, gut wrenching violence You keep getting thrown into the head of someone and given their whole mental landscape for maybe 1 or 2 chapters, before they die in some completely awful way which means you root pretty hard for some people you know are doomed, you find yourself almost applauding the death of some stuck up jerks and then feel bad about it , and you watch helplessly as some real sociopaths mow down one kid after another.
More than anything, this is like watching a horribly violent low budget exploitation movie you see at midnight somewhere there s ZERO surprise it was almost instantly adapted into a movie It s pulp squared, but like many things this aggressively pulpy, it s got a message under there as well Great entertainment for people with a tolerance for high amounts of violence, but also a really well done study of the psychology of extreme fear, and some insights about totalitarianism as well.
I d recommend reading the manga before or instead of the novel for a few reasons For one, it makes it a lot easier to keep up with all the similar sounding names when you have a face to put to it For another thing, you don t have to struggle through a translation that isn t too smooth I felt there were times during the novel where the sentences were disjointed and or abrupt, it wasn t a huge problem for me but I know it will annoy some other readers.
Though I appreciate that the violence in Battle Royale might make some readers queasy, I never found it to be gratuitous like a lot of other people did It s not unrealistic that when people are put into a situation of great fear and distrust they will go to any lengths to survive It s biological If you re in a kill or be killed situation, then nine times out of ten you will choose your own life And if you re in a situation where someone with a gun may or may not be trying to kill you, are you going to ask questions first and risk getting your head blown off Maybe But you re either braver or sillier than most, then.
I am going to compare this to The Hunger Games, though not because I want to make a statement about how Collins plagiarised she probably didn t and, even if she did, no one s going to prove it either way Their similarities just make them good books to use for a comparison fight to the death, teenagers, isolated arena, etc The Hunger Games, as I m sure you all know, focuses on Katniss and her life, the other characters both good and bad are seen solely through her eyes In Battle Royale, the perspective changes frequently I liked it but it may infuriate some and looks at many different types of people.
Though both stories are considered dystopias, I think The Hunger Games world is developed and easier to picture as a reality I have a very clear idea in my mind of the Capitol and the districts, I don t have such a vivid image of this oppressive Japanese state though I don t really think that s the point For me, Battle Royale is a much psychological story, it looks into the dark depths of the human mind and doesn t censor anything it finds I think it s frightening because of the collars that can be made to explode at any time, because of the time limit set on the players, and because all the participants are classmates I also felt there was a greater sense of urgency.
On the other hand, I think The Hunger Games is a emotional read BR is an interesting exploration of the human mind, I liked finding out why the students were able to do what they did, but the only death that really filled me with regret was view spoiler Shinji Mimura hide spoiler